New paper finds another non-hockey-stick in Chile

A new paper published in Climate of the Past reconstructs temperatures in the South American Andes [Chile] and finds temperatures were warmer during the 1940's-1950's than at the end of the record in 2005.

November - February temperature reconstruction for the past 105 years shows warmer temperatures during the 1940's-1950's than at the end of the record in 2005.

Late Holocene summer temperatures in the central Andes reconstructed from the sediments of high-elevation Laguna Chepical, Chile (32° S)

R. de Jong¹, L. von Gunten², A. Maldonado³, and M. Grosjean^1
1Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research & Institute of Geography, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
²PAGES International Project Office, Bern, Switzerland
³Centro de Estudios Avanzados en Zonas Aridas CEAZA, Universidad de La Serena, La Serena, Chile
Abstract. High-resolution reconstructions of climate variability that cover the past millennia are necessary to improve the understanding of natural and anthropogenic climate change across the globe. Although numerous records are available for the mid- and high-latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere, global assessments are still compromised by the scarcity of data from the Southern Hemisphere. This is particularly the case for the tropical and subtropical areas. In addition, high elevation sites in the South American Andes may provide insight into the vertical structure of climate change in the mid-troposphere. This study presents a 3000 yr long austral summer (November to February) temperature reconstruction derived from the ²¹⁰Pb and ¹⁴C dated organic sediments of Laguna Chepical (32°16' S/70°30' W, 3050 m a.s.l.), a high-elevation glacial lake in the subtropical Andes of central Chile. Scanning reflectance spectroscopy in the visible light range provided the spectral index R₅₇₀/R₆₃₀, which reflects the clay mineral content in lake sediments. For the calibration period (AD 1901–2006), the R₅₇₀/R₆₃₀ data were regressed against monthly meteorological reanalysis data, showing that this proxy was strongly and significantly correlated with mean summer (NDJF) temperatures (R_3yr = −0.63, p_adj = 0.01). This calibration model was used to make a quantitative temperature reconstruction back to 1000 BC.

The reconstruction (with a model error RMSEP_boot of 0.33 °C) shows that the warmest decades of the past 3000 yr occurred during the calibration period. The 19th century (end of the Little Ice Age (LIA)) was cool. The prominent warmth reconstructed for the 18th century, which was also observed in other records from this area, seems systematic for subtropical and southern South America but remains difficult to explain. Except for this warm period, the LIA was generally characterized by cool summers. Back to AD 1400, the results from this study compare remarkably well to low altitude records from the Chilean Central Valley and Southern South America. However, the reconstruction from Laguna Chepical does not show a warm Medieval Climate Anomaly during the 12–13th century, which is consistent with records from tropical South America. The Chepical record also indicates substantial cooling prior to 800 BC. This coincides with well-known regional as well as global glacier advances which have been attributed to a grand solar minimum. This study thus provides insight into the climatic drivers and temperature patterns in a region for which currently very few data are available. It also shows that since ca AD 1400, long term temperature patterns were generally similar at low and high altitudes in central Chile.