New paper finds another non-hockey-stick in Siberia; temperatures 'not unprecedented'

A paper published today in Quaternary Science Reviews finds another non-hockey-stick from a tree-ring temperature reconstruction over the past 6,100 years in North Siberia. The authors find, "The recent warming is not unprecedented in the Siberian north. Similar climatic conditions to the present warming were recorded by about [4000 B.C.]." The data shows the tree ring index of relative temperature was ~1.0 at the end of the record in 2008, and warmer [~1.4] in the 1950's, warmer throughout most of the Medieval Warming Period 917-1150 A.D. [index up to 1.6], and warmer during the Climatic Optimum Period 4111–3806 B.C. [index up to 2.3].

Tree ring temperature reconstruction  from 1791-2008 shown in top graph shows relative index was ~1.0 at the end of the record in 2008, and warmer [~1.4] in the 1950's.

Tree ring temperature reconstruction  from 917-1150 during the Medieval Warming Period [MWP] in top graph shows relative index was higher than at the end of the record in 2008 [~1.0] throughout most of the MWP.

Prior posts on non-hockey-sticks

Is the 20th century warming unprecedented in the Siberian north?

• Olga V. Sidorova^a, b, , , , 
• Matthias Saurer^a, 
• Andrei Andreev^c, 
• Diedrich Fritzsche^d, 
• Thomas Opel^d,
• Mukhtar M. Naurzbaev^b, 
• Rolf Siegwolf^a

• ^a Paul Scherrer Institute, 5232 Villigen, Switzerland
• ^b V.N. Sukachev Institute of Forest SB RAS, 660036 Krasnoyarsk, Akademgorodok, Russia
• ^c Institute of Geology and Minerology, 50674 Köln, University of Koeln, Germany
• ^d Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Research Unit Potsdam, 14473 Potsdam, Germany

• http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2013.05.015, How to Cite or Link Using DOI

• Permissions & Reprints

---

Highlights

•

The multi-proxy approach.

•

The combination of classical dendrochronological methods with stable isotope analysis.

•

The recent warming is not unprecedented in the Siberian north.

•

Similar climatic conditions to the present warming were recorded by about 6000 BC. [Note this appears to be a typo, data extends back to 4111 B.C. and suggests correct figure is 4000 B.C.]

•

The Medieval Warm Period was wetter compared to 4111–3850 BC and 1791–2008 AD.

---

Abstract

To answer the question “Has the recent warming no analogues in the Siberian north?” we analyzed larch tree samples (Larix gmelinii Rupr.) from permafrost zone in the eastern Taimyr (TAY) (72°N, 102°E) using tree-ring and stable isotope analyses for the Climatic Optimum Period (COP) 4111–3806 BC and Medieval Warm Period (MWP) 917–1150 AD, in comparison to the recent period (RP) 1791–2008 AD.

We developed a description of the climatic and environmental changes in the eastern Taimyr using tree-ring width and stable isotope (δ¹³C, δ¹⁸O) data based on statistical verification of the relationships to climatic parameters (temperature and precipitation).

Additionally, we compared our new tree-ring and stable isotope data sets with earlier published July temperature and precipitation reconstructions inferred from pollen data of the Lama Lake, Taimyr Peninsula, δ¹⁸O ice core data from Akademii Nauk ice cap on Severnaya Zemlya (SZ) and δ¹⁸O ice core data from Greenland (GISP2), as well as tree-ring width and stable carbon and oxygen isotope data from northeastern Yakutia (YAK).

We found that the COP in TAY was warmer and drier compared to the MWP but rather similar to the RP. Our results indicate that the MWP in TAY started earlier and was wetter than in YAK. July precipitation reconstructions obtained from pollen data of the Lama Lake, oxygen isotope data from SZ and our carbon isotopes in tree cellulose agree well and indicate wetter climate conditions during the MWP.

Consistent large-scale patterns were reflected in significant links between oxygen isotope data in tree cellulose from TAY and YAK, and oxygen isotope data from SZ and GISP2 during the MWP and the RP.

Finally, we showed that the recent warming is not unprecedented in the Siberian north. Similar climate conditions were recorded by tree-rings, stable isotopes, pollen, and ice core data 6000 years ago.